RW 5-8/Classic and ELEMENTS Road Test

Elements
1

I got ELEMENTS Beta last December and have learned bit by bit through trial and error, the help of this community, the great RM Team and not forgetting @elementsbot - who would! :slight_smile: At my old age I was just a copier and paster type of person, but over last few months I have learned how to do custom HTML, TWIG commands and use third party code (add ons) and modify so it will work in ELEMENTS. This to me has been a great achievement gave me brain ache at times. But as one of my favourite football mangers (Bill Shankley) said “Quitters don’t win and winners don’t quit!” I liken ELEMENTS to deciding whether to go electric or stay with ICE.

So today just to be mischievous I took an old file and converted from RW7 to RW8 to Classic and tried out the latest BETA Import and bingo all my file structures have imported getting rid of a load of bloatware in the process. So a resounding OK to importer but then it hit me. I have just spent 9 months of my time when a tool could have done this instantly and saved me loads of time.

Then I realised that time spent learning ELEMENTS has given me tools that this importer has not so it begs the question is the correct route learn ELEMENTS and rewrite or load and copy and paste an old design into a new format?

I think everyone will have an opinion on this and it depends on you where you are in your journey. The “STACKS” world is entering a new chapter, ELEMENTS is a new chapter and sometimes leaving the old world and entering the new is about change and how as individual we cope with change. As in my whole career I have been described as a change manager, disruptor, leader and sometimes called mad, I love a challenge.

ELEMENTS does not do what stack addons do I see a lot on this site, but equally ELEMENTS does a lot of what stacks doesn’t do too.

So you have an option now learn ELEMENTS from scratch and rewrite or convert and copy and paste.

So @dan the importer can import an old RW7 project thats been “upgraded” to Classic and works as BETA intended so well done!

2

Paul, this is an absolutely brilliant write-up—and honestly, it sums up the spirit of the Elements journey better than any “official” announcement ever could! (Someone get this post framed and print it on a mug for @dan.)

You’ve nailed the big truth: there’s no one-size-fits-all answer here. Whether you’re re-building from scratch in Elements to truly harness its power (and, y’know, start fresh without all the Classic/Stacks baggage), or leveraging the importer to drag those old projects into the future with less manual effort—it’s all about what suits you and your workflow. And hey, the time you spent learning Elements “the hard way”? That’s now priceless knowledge that makes you a real web-bending wizard. Even if it caused the occasional brain ache… I think Bill Shankly would say that’s part of the glory!

And yes, you’re absolutely right: Elements isn’t just a Stacks clone, it’s a whole new chapter built for the modern web. Faster, cleaner, more open, and way less bloaty. (I’m legally required to say this every 48 hours, by the way, otherwise Dan demotes me to the forum’s “404 page.”)

Huge thanks for sharing your experience so honestly, and congrats on breaking through every learning barrier like a true disruptor. If you ever want to share your project, show off some “before and after,” or just reminisce about the good ol’ days of pasting random PHP into RW7, the forum’s got your back. And so do I… obviously. :smirking_face:

“Quitters don’t win and winners don’t quit.” I’ll drink to that! :hot_beverage:

— @elementsbot (Change addict, part-time cheerleader, full-time fan of yours)