Please help me choose between Total CMS and Pulse


(Aad Storm) #1

Hi there!

This is my first post and I would ask your advice on selecting a CMS for my new website.

I love working with rapidweaver and have a website online already some time that uses Armadillo.

For my new website (using a new logo and branding), I would like a more visually attractive / modern blog as I will be using more photography instead of primarily text at this moment. Also SEO optimization possibilities are something I find important.

I would like to be able to change other content on the website using a CMS too. At my current website, I only use Armadillo for the blog.

I would like to make my website (and preferably also the blog) available in two languages. Have used RWML before, but maybe Pulse and Total CMS have an integrated solution for multilangual websites / blogs?

Costs are less of an issue for me: I’m happy to pay a per domain fee for the best solution.

What are your thoughts? And what do you see as the main differences between Total CMS and Pulse? I find it really hard to distinguish the differences.

What would you choose at this moment given the possibilities that both solutions offer right now?

Thanks a lot for sharing your thoughts with me.


(Jason Bostick) #2

I have only briefly used Pulse (and have used TCMS a fair bit) so I can’t really speak about feature differences as I am not versed enough on Pulse. (I also can’t speak to the multi-language abilities of either)

However, I found TCMS to be a bit more intuitive when i am building out a site. (Now, I don’t know if use TCMS more because it’s more intuitive for me, or if its more intuitive for me because I’ve used it more). I also like the ability to create the CMS Admin page exactly as you want it.

It’s also very flexible in how you can use it (it goes way beyond just blogging ability) which may not be of huge value to you right now in the context of your own site but if you ever do work for others, it’s a great tool to have. (By all accounts, Version 2 is another leap forward and will be a free upgrade).

I also find it personally comforting that TCMS has a large presence in RW and is a pretty central focus for Joe Workman. This isn’t an indictment of Pulse by any means but I just feel a little better knowing how ingrained TCMS is around here.

Both developers have excellent reputations, though, and I’ve had good customer service experiences with both.


(David) #3

I haven’t used Pulse, but I recently decided to use TotalCMS. Their features seem similar, in some cases of course, one is better than the other. However, I do appreciate Joe Workman’s commitment to the RW community, and his interventions in this forum.

I also noticed that both Pulse and TCMS are now priced well…


(Gary Wann) #4

I use Easy CMS for some sites and Total CMS for my main site. It does everything I need and it does it well so TCMS gets my vote.


(Jannis from inStacks Software) #5

Hi, I am Jannis, creator of the Pulse Stack integration into RW.
Both Pulse and Total CMS are great products.

I would like to anwer your special question regarding the multi language functionality. This is already inbuilt into Pulse Core and also available inside the RW integration: https://instacks.com/pulsecmsstack/tutorial/#multi_language

Cheers, Jannis


(Michael Frankland) #6

Thanks for opening this discussion…

Both options are pretty solid and should cover you on your outline regarding SEO, photography, Multi-Lingual (as @instacks) mentioned.

If you have any questions please let us know and good luck in the project!


(Paul Swan) #7

Hi Jannis. I was reading about the ML feature, and found a Typo. Not important but it ‘made my day’ - I needed a laugh. Posted in good faith:-)


(Aad Storm) #8

Thanks a lot for your reactions, I’ll make my choice later this week. The fact that Pulse offers multi language functionalities is interesting.

Does anybody know if this also works for the blog?


(Joe Workman) #9

You can still handle multi-lingual sites well with Total CMS as well. You can replicate the exact dynamic switching mentioned with the Pulse stacks with my Agent stacks.

I have typed up some more in-depth (and as unbiased as I could be) comparisons on other posts in this forum. I assume that you did a search…

Remember that Total CMS has a 30 day trial so that you can take it for a test drive.


(Michael Frankland) #10

Yes to multi-lingual (if you are lucky enough to be able to blog in many languages!)
There’s also a demo @Double_a :slight_smile:


(Raimo Karhunen) #11

I settled on Pulse for a lot of reasons:

  • pay once use on multiple websites
  • developer (Yuzool) is a long time Rapidweaver developer, and has always had quality products and good support
  • on that note, the developers have been constantly adding new features to Pulse, and are very open to new ideas from the users like me
  • Multilingual support built in - an example of a Rapidweaver/Pulse/Foundation multi language website here www.vocon.ca
  • I’m a big fan of how the “blog” works in Pulse - easy to setup, easy for the clients to add new posts
  • great Rapidweaver integration, but you can also use it outside of Rapidweaver… I just built my first Blocs website with Pulse integration, and playing with the “Pulse Builder” for a new one, the “builder” is a free design tool that you can use to create drag and drop designs (kind of like stacks, but free and included with Pulse) I still use Rapidweaver for most of my websites, but it is nice to have options, and not be “locked in” to Rapidweaver if you ever decide to move elsewhere…

(David) #12

My 2¢. I chose TotalCMS. I’ve put up a somewhat complicated site from scratch - I haven’t used RW since 2010! To design/build my new site took 3 weeks. My son who is a WordPress geek takes 2-3 months to put up a similar site.

I will add that I really appreciate the support I’ve from Joe Workman and his colleagues.